Delivery Robot Accident Claims

When Delivery Robots Collide with People

#

They roll down sidewalks at walking pace, carrying burritos and prescriptions. They fly overhead with packages destined for your doorstep. Delivery robots promised a future where goods arrive autonomously—but that future includes pedestrians struck on sidewalks, cyclists knocked off bikes, and drones crashing into homes.

Unlike most autonomous technology that operates in controlled environments, delivery robots navigate public spaces where vulnerable pedestrians have every right to be. When these machines cause harm, the liability questions span product defects, premises liability, and public safety regulation.

Types of Delivery Robots and Associated Risks

#

Sidewalk Delivery Robots (PEDs)

#

Small wheeled robots sharing pedestrian infrastructure.

Major Operators:

• Starship Technologies
• Serve Robotics
• Kiwibot
• Coco
• Cartken

Physical Characteristics:

• Weight: 40-100 lbs typically
• Speed: 4-6 mph (walking pace)
• Height: knee-level (2-3 feet)
• Navigation: cameras, sensors, GPS

Injury Scenarios:

Drone Delivery (UAVs)

#

Aerial delivery vehicles carrying packages to homes and businesses.

Active Programs:

• Amazon Prime Air
• Wing (Alphabet)
• Zipline
• DroneUp (Walmart)
• Flytrex

Physical Characteristics:

• Weight: 10-55 lbs (with payload)
• Speed: 30-80 mph
• Altitude: typically under 400 feet
• Delivery method: hover-and-lower or landing

Injury Scenarios:

• Strike During Flight — Drone collides with person
• Falling Object — Package dropped, detached, or released improperly
• Crash Into Property — Drone loses control, damages structure or vehicle
• Rotor Contact — Spinning blades contact skin during delivery
• Noise and Disturbance — Repeated operations affecting quality of life
• Wildlife Interaction — Drone crashes after bird strike, debris falls
• Fire — Battery failure causing property ignition

Large Autonomous Delivery Vehicles

#

Full-size autonomous vehicles for package and grocery delivery.

Operators:

• Nuro (R2, R3 vehicles)
• Udelv
• Gatik
• Various retrofitted van platforms

Risks:

• Higher mass than sidewalk robots (hundreds of pounds)
• Faster speeds (up to 25 mph on roads)
• Roadway operation creating vehicle collision risk
• Pedestrian detection challenges in parking areas
• Delivery zone navigation errors

Legal Framework for Delivery Robot Claims

#

Multiple Potential Defendants

#

Delivery robot accidents typically involve multiple liable parties:

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                    DELIVERY ROBOT LIABILITY CHAIN                       │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                                                         │
│  ┌─────────────────┐    ┌─────────────────┐    ┌─────────────────┐    │
│  │ Robot           │    │ Delivery        │    │ Merchant/       │    │
│  │ Manufacturer    │    │ Platform        │    │ Restaurant      │    │
│  │                 │    │                 │    │                 │    │
│  │ Product defect  │    │ Negligent       │    │ Negligent       │    │
│  │ Design flaw     │    │ deployment      │    │ selection of    │    │
│  │ Software error  │    │ Route planning  │    │ delivery method │    │
│  └────────┬────────┘    └────────┬────────┘    └────────┬────────┘    │
│           │                      │                      │              │
│           └──────────────────────┼──────────────────────┘              │
│                                  │                                     │
│                                  ▼                                     │
│           ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐                 │
│           │         Property Owner / Municipality    │                 │
│           │                                         │                 │
│           │  Premises liability for robot presence   │                 │
│           │  Negligent permission of operations      │                 │
│           │  Failure to maintain safe sidewalks      │                 │
│           └─────────────────────────────────────────┘                 │
│                                                                         │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Product Liability

#

Claims against robot and drone manufacturers:

Design Defect:

• Sensor arrays inadequate for pedestrian detection
• Speed settings too high for pedestrian environments
• Obstacle avoidance insufficient for vulnerable users
• Battery design creating fire risk

Manufacturing Defect:

• Individual unit sensor failures
• Motor or brake malfunctions
• Structural weaknesses
• Software bugs in specific units

Failure to Warn:

• Inadequate pedestrian awareness of robot presence
• Missing warnings on robot exterior
• Insufficient notice to hearing/visually impaired
• Lack of emergency stop information for bystanders

Premises Liability

#

Property owners permitting robot operations:

Universities and Campuses:

• Duty to maintain safe premises
• Foreseeable robot-pedestrian conflicts
• Obligations to disabled students and visitors

Shopping Centers and Malls:

• Invitee protection obligations
• Control over robot access
• Security and monitoring duties

Municipalities:

• Sidewalk safety obligations
• Permitting and regulation
• ADA compliance requirements

Negligent Operation

#

Claims against delivery platforms and operators:

• Route planning through high-pedestrian areas
• Operating during dangerous conditions (rain, crowds)
• Inadequate monitoring and intervention
• Failure to respond to near-miss reports
• Excessive deployment density

Regulatory Framework

#

Delivery robot operations face fragmented regulation:

State Personal Delivery Device Laws: Most states now have PED (Personal Delivery Device) legislation addressing:

• Maximum weight and speed limits
• Sidewalk operation permission
• Yield requirements
• Insurance mandates
• Operator registration

Case Studies

#

Building a Delivery Robot Case

#

Evidence Collection

#

Scene Evidence:

• Exact location of incident (GPS coordinates)
• Sidewalk/path conditions and width
• Presence of obstacles or obstructions
• Weather and visibility conditions
• Witness contact information
• Photos/video of robot and location
• Surveillance camera footage (act quickly—often overwritten)

Robot Evidence:

• Robot identification number/marking
• Operating company
• Robot condition post-incident
• Any visible damage or malfunction indicators
• Alert lights or sounds operating

Injury Documentation:

• Medical records from all treatments
• Photos of injuries (immediate and healing)
• Impact on mobility and daily activities
• Pre-existing conditions that may have been aggravated

Operator Data (via discovery):

• Robot sensor logs and camera footage
• Route planning and decision data
• Prior incidents with same robot
• Prior incidents at same location
• Speed and path data at time of incident
• Operator intervention capability and response

ADA and Accessibility Claims

#

Delivery robots may violate Americans with Disabilities Act requirements:

Potential ADA Violations:

• Obstructing sidewalk minimum clear width
• Creating hazards for visually impaired pedestrians
• Blocking wheelchair accessible routes
• Failing to yield to mobility devices
• Operating without adequate warning for hearing impaired

Enforcement Options:

• Private lawsuits for injunctive relief
• Damages for access denial and injury
• Complaints to DOJ Civil Rights Division
• State and local civil rights agencies

Expert Witnesses

#

Damages in Delivery Robot Cases

#

Categories of Recovery

#

Personal Injury:

• Medical expenses (emergency, ongoing, future)
• Lost wages and earning capacity
• Pain and suffering
• Disability and impairment
• Loss of enjoyment of life
• Emotional distress

Property Damage:

• Vehicle damage from collision
• Home damage from drone crash
• Personal property destruction

Access-Related Damages:

• Cost of alternative routes/transportation
• Inability to access services
• Dignitary harm from exclusion
• Accommodation expenses

Factors Affecting Case Value

#

Pedestrian Rights and Robot Operations

#

The Public Space Question

#

Sidewalks are public spaces designed for pedestrians. Key legal questions:

Who Has Priority?

• Pedestrians have traditional right-of-way on sidewalks
• Robots are non-human occupants without inherent rights
• Commercial activity on public property requires permission
• Disabled pedestrians have ADA-protected access rights

Permitting and Permission:

• Most cities now require delivery robot permits
• Permits may limit locations, hours, and density
• Violations of permit conditions may establish negligence per se
• Municipalities may be liable for inadequate permitting

Insurance Requirements:

• Many jurisdictions require liability insurance
• Insurance may be inadequate for serious injuries
• Uninsured operation may create enhanced liability

Future Regulatory Trends

#

Expected Developments:

• Stricter pedestrian detection requirements
• Mandatory accessibility accommodations
• Hours of operation restrictions
• Density limits on robot populations
• Enhanced insurance minimums
• Performance standards and testing requirements

Frequently Asked Questions

#

Find a Delivery Robot Accident Attorney

#

Delivery robot cases require attorneys who understand:

• Pedestrian rights and sidewalk law
• Product liability for autonomous systems
• ADA and accessibility requirements
• Municipal permitting and regulation
• Multi-defendant litigation strategy
• Rapid evidence preservation needs